A lot of “experts” are getting bent out of shape over pretty
much anything Pope Francis says these days.
Take, for instance, his answer to somebody’s question as to whether he
might retire as Pope Benedict XVI did.
Pope Francis’s answer was to the effect that, sure, it’s possible. Immediately the pundits and commentators
started discussing papal retirement as if it were an established fact and was
scheduled for a few months from now. You
see the same thing every now and then when somebody asks whether it’s possible
that Queen Elizabeth II could abdicate.
Sure she could. Is it
likely? Hardly.
Tuesday, June 3, 2014
Monday, June 2, 2014
The Philosophical PhaceBook: Knowledge v. Opinion
As we’ve noted a number of times on this blog, some of our
best postings are written by other people, or at least in response to questions
and issues raised. The rather unexpected
popularity of the recent short series on Anti-Trust Law written mostly by Judge
Peter Stenger Grosscup (1852-1921) is a case in point. That’s why it’s so gratifying to receive a
comment like the following:
Friday, May 30, 2014
News from the Network, Vol. 7, No. 22
The news from the financial front is that the stock market
is still soaring, but people still seem to be poor. At the same time, the “gold bugs” are
claiming that a return to “the gold standard” is the silver bullet (sorry)
needed to cure our economic ills and balance the budget.
Thursday, May 29, 2014
Do We Own Our Social Security Accounts?, III: The Solution
The whole issue of Social Security that we’ve been looking
at and the “unbooked” liability that, combined with projected Medicare and the
prescription drug liabilities, is upwards of $129 trillion (yes, trillion,
or nearly ten times total U.S. annual GDP) per the “National Debt Clock” would be a non-issue if
the U.S. would adopt a Capital Homestead Act along the lines recommended in Capital
Homesteading for Every Citizen: A Just Free Market Approach for Saving Social
Security (2004).
Wednesday, May 28, 2014
Do We Own Our Social Security Accounts?, II: The Situation
While we appreciate the sentiments expressed by the Lady in
Montana given in the previous posting, and agree that, under the influence of
Keynesian economics, politicians have been bleeding the productive private
sector dry in favor of unproductive government spending and private sector
speculation and gambling, the simple fact is that we do not own the money that
we have paid into “our” Social Security accounts. Social Security was
designed as a redistribution program in which those paying the tax (and note
that it is a tax, not a contribution) support those receiving benefits.
Tuesday, May 27, 2014
Do We Own Our Social Security Accounts?, I: The Complaint
A little while back we got a forwarded e-mail from a
correspondent who occasionally sends us . . . provocative materials. This
piece, with the subject line, “Do You Think She’s Pissed?” contains language
that really doesn’t have a place in a learned forum such as this, but it would
detract from the overall impression to delete it. We don’t even know if this thing is real, but
that’s not the point: it expresses what many people believe Social Security to
be, i.e., a bank account with our
money in it, earning interest for our retirement.
Monday, May 26, 2014
Guest Posting: A Critical Response
Every so often (like every couple of hours or so) we get a
response or a comment from someone who seems to have seen a word or two he or
she disagrees with in something we said or wrote, and shoots off a comment
before checking to see if his or her brain is loaded. Usually the comment has nothing to do with
what we actually said, but everything to do with what the commentator thinks we said, based on unquestioned
assumptions of the commentator.
Friday, May 23, 2014
News from the Network, Vol. 7, No. 21
Stock market soar like eagle . . . by suckering in
turkeys. Frankly, the wild swings in the
stock market really ought to make people a lot more nervous than it does. The same sort of thing was happening about
this time in 1929.
Thursday, May 22, 2014
“Inspired Amateurs Should Avoid Politics”
On May 12, 2014, the Wall
Street Journal carried an op-ed piece that was truly opposed to what the newspaper
claims to stand for. (Contrary to
popular opinion, “op-ed” doesn’t mean “opinion-editorial,” but “opposite the
editorial page.” An op-ed piece
presumably reflects the personal opinion of the writer, not necessarily the
official stance of the newspaper. Look
it up.)
Wednesday, May 21, 2014
Grosscup on Anti-Trust Laws, VII: Workers Should Be Owners
Today we close our short series consisting of the full text
of Judge Peter S. Grosscup’s “long lost” talk on anti-trust legislation from
October of 1907 — right after financier J. Pierpont Morgan caused the “Panic of
1907” by taking advantage of the financial mismanagement and shenanigans by the
management of an important bank. As
Grosscup concluded,
Tuesday, May 20, 2014
Grosscup on Anti-Trust Laws, VI: National Commission on Corporation Reform
![]() |
| Cohan as Wallingford |
Monday, May 19, 2014
Grosscup on Anti-Trust Laws, V: Securing an Interest in Combinations
This portion of Judge Grosscup’s talk brings in an
assumption with which we disagree: that the process of capital formation in an
advanced economy necessarily means that enterprises must be big, bigger, and
biggest just to survive. On the
contrary, given the use of future savings to finance new capital formation and
the operation of a truly free market, enterprises should be the optimal size
for efficiency, not big or small to fit preconceived ideas. This does not, however, invalidate the point
Grosscup was making. As he continued,
Friday, May 16, 2014
News from the Network, Vol. 7, No. 20
Most of this week was spent “cleaning up” from prior
meetings, or arranging or preparing for future meetings. Nevertheless, we did commit a few newsworthy
acts:
Thursday, May 15, 2014
Grosscup on Anti-Trust Laws, IV: Diffusion of Wealth in the United States
With all the discussion, acrimonious and otherwise, stirred
up by Pope Francis’s tweet about inequality being the root of all social evil,
it’s interesting to see that Judge Grosscup was saying pretty much the same
thing more than a century ago. As His
Honor continued,
Wednesday, May 14, 2014
Grosscup on Anti-Trust Laws, III: Our Legislation Wrong in Principle
Here is the second part of Judge Grosscup’s talk on
Anti-Trust Laws given in Chicago in October 1907, and lost until rediscovered
recently by CESJ researchers. Judge
Grosscup continued,
Tuesday, May 13, 2014
Grosscup on Anti-Trust Laws, II: Opening Remarks
The following talk is taken from Proceedings on the National Conference on Trusts and Combinations Under
the Auspices of the National Civic Federation, October 22-25, 1907, New
York: The McConnell Printing Company, 1908, pp. 11, 221-231. . . . which title probably
explains why this insightful talk was “long lost.” It wouldn’t be at the top of too many reading
lists being included in a book with a title like that.
Monday, May 12, 2014
Grosscup on Anti-Trust Laws, I: Introduction
It seems singularly appropriate to begin this series at this
time, as the annual ESOP Association Conference was held in Washington, DC. The awards ceremony was last Wednesday night,
as a matter of fact, and EEI’s biggest for-profit client, Mid South Building Supply, won some prestigious awards.
Friday, May 9, 2014
News from the Network, Vol. 7, No. 19
Most of the CESJ core group was busy this week with
“outside” activities. Nevertheless, a
number of projects saw significant advances, although not in ways that make for
good news items. Events that do make
good stories are:
Thursday, May 8, 2014
Some Thoughts on Atheism, V: Will and Intellect
Replacing reason with faith, as the solidarist political
scientist and jurist Heinrich Rommen pointed out in his book on the natural
law, is the inevitable consequence of putting your private interpretation of
the Will (opinion/faith) over Intellect (knowledge/reason), and leads (as Adler
concurred) to pure moral relativism, even nihilism, and is the basis of
totalitarian government. Everything ends
up being opinion. Knowledge itself
becomes fit only for ridicule. Might makes
right.
Wednesday, May 7, 2014
Some Thoughts on Atheism, IV: Faith v. Reason
Many atheists mistake materialism for science. It is true that you cannot prove the
existence of God by deduction. You
cannot put God in a test tube or under a microscope and subject Him to various experiments. You cannot prove the existence of an
immaterial being by material means.
Tuesday, May 6, 2014
Ukraine: The Free Trade Solution
Someone made an interesting suggestion about the crisis in
Ukraine. The current push for sanctions
that doesn’t seem to be having any effect may not be the best way to go. The country is in a state of disunity. Making things worse doesn’t make things any
better.
Monday, May 5, 2014
Some Thoughts on Atheism, III: Wiederspruch (Contradiction)
The habit of some religious believers of espousing a type of
“muscular Christianity” (or Judaism, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, or anything
else) and attempting to bully people into believing their way has probably
spawned more atheism than anything else.
Nobody likes a bully, and religious people can come across as (and
sometimes are) bullies attempting to force others to do their will — or God’s
Will, as they imagine it to be. An
atheist (or anyone else) is fully justified in thinking that any god that needs
that kind of help can’t be much of a supreme being.
Friday, May 2, 2014
News from the Network, Vol. 7, No. 18
Some very interesting things have been happening this week .
. . some of the best of which we can’t tell you anything about because they’re
still in the formative stages. We do
have enough, however, to show that we’re starting to make some significant
progress:
Thursday, May 1, 2014
“Inequality is the Root of All Social Evil”
We interrupt our regularly scheduled blog posting to bring
you an important news bulletin. On
Monday, April 28, 2014, Pope Francis did it again. He completely baffled both “liberals” and
“conservatives.” He “tweeted” a short
message (as if there can be extended discussion in a tweet): “Inequality is the
root of all social evil.”
Wednesday, April 30, 2014
Some Thoughts on Atheism, II: Knowledge v. Opinion
Yesterday we saw that atheists (if they are being honest)
hold their beliefs by faith just as much as believers in a deity. The catch here for both atheists and theists,
and the cause of much of the acrimony today over many things, not just
religion, is that opinion may or may
not be true, whereas knowledge is
certainly true.
Tuesday, April 29, 2014
Some Thoughts on Atheism, I: Are Atheists the Enemy?
The canonizations of Pope John Paul II and John XXIII this
past Sunday have caused a significant amount of discussion, some positive, some
negative. Much of it revealed a great misunderstanding
of what, exactly, a “saint” is. That’s
not our concern.
Monday, April 28, 2014
Statism v. Catholic Social Teaching, III: “Monsignor New Deal”
Whether Pope Leo XIII really issued Rerum Novarum in part to refute the theories of the agrarian
socialist Henry George is a debatable point . . . at least until we can get to
the Vatican archives and do a little more research. It is not, however, debatable that Henry
George and a number of his modern followers believe that the pope singled out
George for criticism.
Friday, April 25, 2014
News from the Network, Vol. 7, No. 17
This week’s news items cover some items that you’ll never
see in other newsletters, from newly canonized saints to the “Greek world” of sororities
and fraternities. Of great importance
are the possible for-profit connections that are being made.
Thursday, April 24, 2014
Statism v. Catholic Social Teaching, II: Rerum Novarum
Despite the fact that the Catholic Church has unequivocally
condemned socialism, the idea that the State is the real owner of everything
and can tax and redistribute for social purposes at will has pervaded Catholic
social teaching since at least the mid-1880s.
This was when the agrarian socialist Henry George and Archbishop Michael
A. Corrigan of New York went at it hammer and tongs.
Wednesday, April 23, 2014
Statism v. Catholic Social Teaching, I: The Role of Taxation
One of our vast crowd of readers commented in response to
yesterday’s posting that mentioned Daniel Webster’s dictum from the
Massachusetts Constitutional Convention of 1820 (“Power naturally and
necessarily follows property”), “Maybe that's why the State
taxes us for owning property, and in extreme cases exercises eminent domain —
just so we always remember who’s ‘boss’.”
Tuesday, April 22, 2014
Galloping Into Moral Relativism
There has been some talk recently (i.e., over the past century or so) about the need to call a halt to
all the judicial activism that’s been going on, what some people have called
“legislation by judiciary.” The fact is
that Congress (whether it meant to or not) has lost a great deal of the power
the people grant to it in the Constitution, that the Executive (the president)
and, especially, the Supreme Court have picked up.
Monday, April 21, 2014
A Plague on Both Your Houses, III: The American Revolutionary Party
This posting is not an endorsement of the American
Revolutionary Party. The American
Revolutionary Party has a platform incorporating elements of the Just Third
Way, but any other political party on earth is free to adopt any or all
elements of the Just Third Way as well — and we wish they would.
Friday, April 18, 2014
News from the Network, Vol. 7, No. 16
An objective observer of recent political and economic
events might conclude that the world is reliving the first half of the 20th
century with a vengeance. The domestic
political and economic situation, the stock market fluctuations, events in
Europe . . . all seemed designed to make students of history very nervous. As Herbert Knox Smith summed up the situation
more than a century ago,
Thursday, April 17, 2014
A Plague on Both Your Houses, II: Democrats
Yesterday we told you what is wrong with the Republican
emphasis on cost-cutting to balance the budget and restore fiscal sanity. Today we are going to tell you what is wrong
with the Democratic emphasis on increasing spending, both to meet people’s
needs directly, and to stimulate the economy to create jobs that will,
presumably, allow people to meet their own needs through their own efforts.
Wednesday, April 16, 2014
A Plague on Both Your Houses, I: Republicans
A few weeks ago both the Wall
Street Journal and the Washington
Post went into great depth on Representative Paul Ryan’s 98-page budget
proposal that Ryan believes would balance the budget in a decade. The Wall
Street Journal seemed to like it.
The Washington Post wasn’t
quite as enthusiastic.
Tuesday, April 15, 2014
Focus on the Fed, VI: Capital Homesteading, A Realistic Solution
As we saw in yesterday’s posting, many factors
have combined to put propertyless workers (and everyone else without capital)
into a very bad position. The wealth and
income gap continues to grow, while attempts to deal with it from within
conventional frameworks only make the situation worse.
Monday, April 14, 2014
Focus on the Fed, V: Concentration of Wealth and the Income Gap
Last week the 10th annual Rally at the
Fed drew attention to some serious problems in the monetary and fiscal policy
being followed by the world’s central banks, especially the Federal
Reserve. Used today almost exclusively
to finance government, they were intended to be the lender of last resort for
the private sector, not the money machine of first resort for government.
Friday, April 11, 2014
News from the Network, Vol. 7, No. 15
Again, the Big News is today’s Rally at the Fed. Other than that, most of the efforts this
week have been directed at preparing for the rally and the CESJ celebration
tomorrow. Still, a few things have been
happening:
Thursday, April 10, 2014
Focus on the Fed, IV: Elastic Reserve Currency
In yesterday’s posting we stressed the importance
of having a reserve currency — or any other weight or measure — that has a
standard and stable value, and is asset-backed.
In today’s posting, we take a look at why, while a stable standard is
absolutely critical, “elasticity,” that is, a money supply that expands and
contracts with the needs of the economy, is also important, especially in a
rapidly growing economy, or one in which most of the participants are not
personally known to one another.
Wednesday, April 9, 2014
Focus on the Fed, III: Banking and Reserve Currency
As we saw yesterday, a stable and standard
currency is of the utmost importance to maintain a stable economic and
political situation. The problem we look
at today is how to maintain a stable and standard currency, especially when
there are many different types of money in an economy.
Tuesday, April 8, 2014
Focus on the Fed, II: Say’s Law, or, No Consumption Without Production
As we saw in yesterday’s posting, the monetary
reforms of the Just Third Way assume as a given that the purpose of production
is consumption. This is the basis of
“Say’s Law of Markets,” which both Karl Marx and John Maynard Keynes reject.
Monday, April 7, 2014
Focus on the Fed, I: How the Federal Reserve Creates Money
This piece is intended to orient the reader and
frame the discussion presented in “A New Look at Prices and Money” by Norman G.
Kurland. “Prices and Money” was first
published in The Journal of
Socio-Economics (Vol. 30, pp 495-515), and is available online from the CESJ website.
Friday, April 4, 2014
News from the Network, Vol. 7, No. 14
Most of what happened this week has been in preparation of
the 10th annual Rally at the Fed, and CESJ’s 30th
anniversary celebration. We expect to
have a great deal more to report next Friday, although the news notes will be
posted even later than this week to be able to report on the rally.
Thursday, April 3, 2014
“Dangerously Low Inflation”
It was a rather startling thing to read in the lead article
of the Wall Street Journal — but it
was there. On Wednesday, March 26, 2014,
in the article on page A1 titled, “ECB Set To Mull Heavier Stimulus,” the
venerable Wall Street Journal had the
sentence, “European Central Bank officials . . . are willing to consider
dramatic steps to guard against dangerously low inflation.”
Wednesday, April 2, 2014
A Proper Response
The other day someone sent around an e-mail suggesting that
violence could solve many of today’s massive social and economic problems. From a certain perspective, that is
correct. The idea that “violence never
solved anything” is, frankly, just plain wrong.
Violence solves a lot of problems.
It just usually leaves you with much bigger problems than you started
with.
Tuesday, April 1, 2014
Is Justice Reasonable? Absolutely!
It hardly comes as a surprise to any Aristotelian-Thomist,
but a recent scientific study
suggests that a concern for justice is linked not to emotion, but to
reason. This supports the contention
that justice, a moral virtue, and, by extension, all moral virtues, is an act
of the Intellect, not of the Will; an absolute, not subject to change to
reflect the needs of the moment or fitted to expedients, however useful or
desired.
Monday, March 31, 2014
Before Rerum Novarum, V: Corrigan Quotes Leo XIII
We finish off our short series on Archbishop Michael A.
Corrigan’s 1886 pastoral letter by quoting Corrigan quoting Leo XIII. We realize that this could get a little
complicated if somebody quotes us, and then somebody quotes somebody quoting us
. . .
Friday, March 28, 2014
News from the Network, Vol. 7, No. 13
Plans are being finalized for the annual Rally at the Fed
and the CESJ 30th Anniversary Celebration. The fact that CESJ has been in existence
since 1984, and is strengthening its support base is a victory in itself, to
say nothing about the fact that it is becoming increasingly obvious with each
passing day that the Just Third Way is the only realistic and practicable plan
for what Pope Pius XI called “the restructuring of the social order” to restore
what Abraham Lincoln believed to be “the last, best hope of earth.”
Thursday, March 27, 2014
Before Rerum Novarum, IV: Corrigan on the Rights of Property
In yesterday’s posting, we quoted from Archbishop Michael A.
Corrigan’s 1886 pastoral that, in part, addressed certain issues raised by
agrarian socialist Henry George during his bid for mayor of New York City that
year. Corrigan first laid out the basis
of the Catholic Church’s position — what we saw yesterday — and then proceeded
to explain how these applied to private property . . . which is today’s
posting:
Wednesday, March 26, 2014
Before Rerum Novarum, III: Corrigan Speaks
As promised, today we begin posting the relevant portions of
Archbishop Michael Corrigan’s 1886 pastoral letter as published Saturday,
November 27, 1886, in the New York
Freeman’s Journal and Catholic Register.
One or two spellings and punctuation marks were changed to reflect
modern usage. We do have the whole
thing, and are planning on putting it in as an appendix to a book we’re working
on now, but most of it doesn’t directly address the question of private
property.
Tuesday, March 25, 2014
Before Rerum Novarum, II: Faith v. Reason
CESJ is not Catholic, but we rely heavily on Catholic social
teachings, which (as Pius XII emphasized in the opening paragraphs of his 1950
encyclical, Humani Generis) can be
discerned by “human
reason by its own natural force and light.”
Monday, March 24, 2014
Before Rerum Novarum, I: The Setting
In 1886 the agrarian socialist Henry George ran for mayor of
New York City as the Union Labor Party candidate. His opponents were the reforming Democratic
candidate, Abram Stevens Hewitt, and Theodore Roosevelt on the Republican
ticket. Hewitt won, George came in
second, and Roosevelt finished a distant third.
Friday, March 21, 2014
News from the Network, Vol. 7, No. 12
It is interesting to see how the stock market reacts to
news. What news is irrelevant, or
whether it’s good or bad. The fact is
that with the speed of trades increased through the use of electronic media,
the market can react instantly to anything and everything, and the gamblers and
speculators are, of course, experts at making money whichever way it goes.
Thursday, March 20, 2014
Economic Emancipation, III: Why NOT Capital Homesteading?
Yesterday we looked at some of the positive baggage loaded
on to the term “Capital Homesteading.”
Yes, we know that “baggage” is often used in a pejorative sense, but try
and travel anywhere without it for any length of time.
Wednesday, March 19, 2014
Economic Emancipation, II: The Etymology (Sort of) of Capital Homesteading
In yesterday’s posting we described how we arrived at the
term “Economic Emancipation.” We had
been discussing whether the term “Capital Homesteading” was appropriate, and
started tossing possible new terms around.
The end result was that we decided to consider adding “Economic
Emancipation,” but without subtracting “Capital Homesteading.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
