You would have thought that with a blog name like “The Just Third Way Blog” we would have addressed this issue a few years or even a decade or so ago. Well, better late than never, to be original. It was, after all, only last week that someone raised the issue with us, and then within a rather specialized milieu.
![]() |
| Pope John Paul II |
Before beginning, however, we have to issue a caveat. CESJ is not a Catholic or even a religious organization. We do, however, work with many religious individuals and organizations, as well as anyone else interested in the principles of a just economy. So, during a conversation last week, someone asked why CESJ insists on calling our proposal a “third way” when in § 41 of Solicitudo Rei Socialis Pope John Paul II declared Catholic social teaching is not a “third way.” Specifically,
The Church’s social doctrine is not a “third way” between liberal capitalism and Marxist collectivism, nor even a possible alternative to other solutions less radically opposed to one another: rather, it constitutes a category of its own. Nor is it an ideology, but rather the accurate formulation of the results of a careful reflection on the complex realities of human existence, in society and in the international order, in the light of faith and of the Church’s tradition. Its main aim is to interpret these realities, determining their conformity with or divergence from the lines of the Gospel teaching on man and his vocation, a vocation which is at once earthly and transcendent; its aim is thus to guide Christian behavior. It therefore belongs to the field, not of ideology, but of theology and particularly of moral theology.
This is not really a problem. Given what is said in this passage, there is no conflict between Catholic social teaching and the Just Third Way of Economic Personalism. At the most basic level, both Catholic social teaching and the Just Third Way of Economic Personalism agree on the same natural law principles. It is only when the issue of applying those principles arises that there is any confusion, and such confusion is rooted in the tendency of many commentators to “mix apples and oranges.”
![]() |
| Thomas Aquinas |
Adherents of Economic Personalism agree, in fact, rely on there being only one truth. (Thomas Aquinas, De Unitate Intellectus Contra Averroistas, “On the Unity of the Intellect Against the Averroists”). Consequently, knowledge of the natural law, a manifestation of that truth common to both the Just Third Way of Economic Personalism and Catholic social teaching, can be known through “human reason by its own natural force and light.” (Humani Generis, § 2.) In that sense, there is not, nor could there ever be, a third way or even a second way.
It is when we begin applying the principles of Catholic social teaching that we run up against all the myriad ways in which truth can be interpreted and applied. The Catholic Church does not endorse or teach any specific application of its social principles to civil society, over which it has authority only insofar as the civil order affects matters of faith or morals — which are the purview of the Church, not the State.
Given that, we divide virtually all applications (or lack thereof) of Catholic social teaching in the economic realm into what many people assume are two mutually exclusive categories. These constitute what many also assume are the only possibilities: capitalism and socialism. That’s not just in the Catholic Church, of course. This view is pervasive throughout society.
Further, defining socialism as the abolition of private property as a natural right (violating the generic right of dominion), and capitalism as the distortion of private property as a natural right (violating the universal destination of all goods), necessarily implies a system in which the natural right of private property is neither abolished nor distorted. Rather, the institution of private property is open to every child, woman, and man within a justly structured social order which respects the dignity of every human person. This system we call the Just Third Way of Economic Personalism.
Again, in the realm of truth and fundamental principles, as John Paul II infallibly declared, there is no “third way,” and we agree. In the realm of application, however, among the vast and chaotic universe of applications where the Church can make no infallible judgment and given the presumption of a division between capitalism on one hand and socialism on the other, we believe there is a third way, which works to apply the one, true way of justice: the Just Third Way of Economic Personalism.
So, no, there is no third way in one sense, and yes, there is a third way in another sense. The question then becomes, what is the purpose of Catholic social teaching?
That is another whole issue.
#30#


